The Hawaii Supreme Court struck down Maui Planning Commission rules that had exempted certain construction and renovation projects near the shoreline from requiring Special Management Area permits. The court found the exemptions violated the Coastal Zone Management Act by bypassing required case-by-case environmental review.
- The court ruled that Maui’s 2024 categorical permit exemptions for SMA projects — including structural renovations, paving, trenching, and EV charger installations — were unlawful under state coastal management law.
- Projects in Maui’s Special Management Area, which covers vulnerable shoreline zones, must now again go through individual permit review and a public hearing process.
- The ruling restores the requirement that the Maui Planning Commission assess each project individually before deciding whether a permit is needed.
- Property owners or developers near the shoreline planning improvements or infrastructure work may now face longer permitting timelines.
- The case was brought by environmental nonprofit Maui Tomorrow Foundation, which argued the rules improperly shifted environmental oversight responsibility to developers themselves.
Source: Alohastatedaily
Share this article
